| MVP | Jake Lewis |
| Cy Young | Jake Lewis |
| Rookie of the Year | Blake Imhoff |
| Gold Glove | Nik Mattson |
| Silver Slugger | Eric Hinnenkamp |
| Reliever of the Year | Brock McDermid |
| Comeback Player of the Year | Nik Mattson Taavi Mattson Brock McDermid |
| Mr. Versatility | Owen Hindermann Eric Hinnenkamp Brock McDermid |
| MVP | Alex Busick |
| Cy Young | Jake Lewis |
| Rookie of the Year | Joe Udd |
| Gold Glove | Ethan Raye |
| Silver Slugger | Alex Busick |
| Reliever of the Year | Isaac Fugere |
| Comeback Player of the Year | Noah Hobbs |
| Mr. Versatility | Conner Fonger Tucker Johnson |
2021 Lake Superior Sea Dogs
Conner Fonger
Ben Rhodes
Justin Sedin
Isaac Fugere
Ben Rhodes
Mitch Kruger
2020 Lake Superior Sea Dogs
| MVP | Jake Lewis |
| Cy Young | Jake Lewis |
| Rookie of the Year | Nick Baker |
| Gold Glove | Nick Baker Cooper Grashorn |
| Silver Slugger | Seth Anderson |
| Reliever of the Year | Mitch Kruger |
| MVP | Jake Lewis |
| Cy Young | Jake Lewis |
| Rookie of the Year | Andy Kaptonak Carson Wenger |
| Gold Glove | Carson Wenger |
| Silver Slugger | Mike Karp |
| Reliever of the Year | N/A |
| Comeback Player of the Year | Pete Atiemo Kevin Hendrickx Mike Karp Jesse Olson |
| Mr. Versatility | Seth Anderson |
| MVP | Peter Lenz Jake Lewis |
| Cy Young | Peter Lenz Jake Lewis |
| Rookie of the Year | Jacob Becks |
| Gold Glove | Chris Olson |
| Silver Slugger | Derek Haedrich |
| Reliever of the Year | Seth Anderson |
| Comeback Player of the Year | N/A |
| Mr. Versatility | Seth Anderson Derrick Winn |
| None Awarded |
| MVP | Jake Lewis Jimmy Merling |
| Cy Young | Jake Lewis |
| Rookie of the Year | Brendan Burnap Michael Gales |
| Gold Glove | Bob Baxton Jimmy Merling |
| Silver Slugger | Jimmy Merling |
| Reliever of the Year | Anthony Bush |
| Comeback Player of the Year | Peyton Flanders |
| Mr. Versatility | Travis Bartlett Cody Dolsen |
| MVP | Travis Bartlett Jimmy Merling |
| Cy Young | Jake Lewis |
| Rookie of the Year | Trenton Moe |
| Gold Glove | Trenton Moe |
| Silver Slugger | Jimmy Merling |
| Reliever of the Year | Anthony Bush |
| Comeback Player of the Year | Travis Bartlett Bob Baxton Anthony Bush Kevin Hendrickx Jake Lewis |
| Mr. Versatility | Travis Bartlett |
| MVP | Jimmy Merling |
| Cy Young | Jake Lewis |
| Rookie of the Year | Jimmy Merling |
| Gold Glove | Jimmy Merling Tim Nylund |
| Silver Slugger | Jimmy Merling |
| Reliever of the Year | Matt Dolsen |
| Comeback Player of the Year | Corey Pavlich |
| Mr. Versatility | Travis Bartlett |
| MVP | Nick Moran Tim Nylund |
| Cy Young | Anthony Bush |
| Silver Slugger | Nick Moran |
| Gold Glove | Kevin Hendrickx |
| Rookie of the Year | Jake Lewis |
| Reliever of the Year | Jake Lewis |
| Mr. Versatility | Kevin Hendrickx |
| Comeback Player of the Year | Corey Pavlich |
| MVP | Anthony Bush Jesse Olson |
| Cy Young | Anthony Bush Jesse Olson |
| Silver Slugger | Matt Chruscielski |
| Gold Glove | Tim Nylund |
| Rookie of the Year | Jesse Olson |
| Reliever of the Year | Jesse Olson |
| Mr. Versatility | Kevin Hendrickx |
| Comeback Player of the Year | Tim Nylund |
| MVP | Bob Eastman |
| Cy Young | Chris Vendela |
| Silver Slugger | Bob Eastman |
| Gold Glove | Kevin Olson Corey Pavlich |
| Rookie of the Year | Keith Gunderson |
| Reliever of the Year | Keith Gunderson |
| Mr. Versatility | Corey Pavlich |
| Comeback Player of the Year | Matt Chruscielski |
| MVP | Anthony Bush |
| Cy Young | Anthony Bush |
| Silver Slugger | Mike Gerard |
| Gold Glove | Tim Nylund |
| Rookie of the Year | Zack Bauers |
| Reliever of the Year | Bob Baxton |
| Mr. Versatility | Kyle Cotrell |
| Comeback Player of the Year | Mike Gerard |
| MVP | Dan Solarz |
| Cy Young | Anthony Bush |
| Silver Slugger | Dan Solarz |
| Gold Glove | Matt Chruscielski |
| Rookie of the Year | James Ostrander |
| Mr. Versatility | Kyle Cotrell Dan Solarz |
| Comeback Player of the Year | Corey Pavlich |
| MVP | Joe Collier Al Schmidt |
| Cy Young | Anthony Bush Kyle Hall |
| Silver Slugger | Nick Koubsky |
| Gold Glove | Corey Pavlich |
| Rookie of the Year | Al Schmidt |
| Reliever of the Year | Joe Collier |
| Mr. Versatility | Nick Koubsky |
| MVP | Steve Halvorson |
| Cy Young | Nick Koubsky |
| Silver Slugger | Steve Halvorson |
| Gold Glove | Jason Melander |
| Rookie of the Year | Buddy Carlson |