Most Dukes career records were expanded by the current leader in 2016, with the exceptions of Jimmy Merling tying Bob Baxton for doubles, and Baxton surpassing Corey Pavlich for total bases.
| CATEGORY | PLAYER | VALUE | PREVIOUS RECORD | PLAYER |
| On Base Pct. | Jimmy Merling | .457 | .460 | Jimmy Merling |
| Slugging Pct. | Jimmy Merling | .553 | .605 | Jimmy Merling |
| Batting Avg. | Jimmy Merling | .367 | .377 | Jimmy Merling |
| Doubles | Bob Baxton Jimmy Merling |
20 | 18 | Bob Baxton |
| Home Runs | Jimmy Merling | 6 | 5 | Jimmy Merling |
| Total Bases | Bob Baxton | 142 | 128 | Corey Pavlich |
| Runs Batted In | Bob Baxton | 56 | 48 | Bob Baxton |
| Sacrifice Hits | Kevin Hendrickx | 21 | 17 | Kevin Hendrickx |
| Sacrifice Flies | Travis Bartlett | 7 | 6 | Travis Bartlett |
| Strikeout % | Jimmy Merling | 5.9 | 6.2 | Jimmy Merling |
| Walks/Strikeouts | Jimmy Merling | 2.50 | 2.20 | Jimmy Merling |
| CATEGORY | PITCHER | VALUE | PREVIOUS RECORD | PITCHER |
| Earned Run Average | Jake Lewis | 3.14 | 3.21 | Jake Lewis |
| Games | Anthony Bush | 112 | 97 | Anthony Bush |
| Games Started | Anthony Bush | 85 | 82 | Anthony Bush |
| Complete Games | Anthony Bush | 19 | 18 | Anthony Bush |
| Wins | Anthony Bush | 24 | 23 | Anthony Bush |
| Innings Pitched | Anthony Bush | 510.1 | 479.2 | Anthony Bush |
| Strikeouts | Anthony Bush | 331 | 309 | Anthony Bush |
| Walks/9 IP | Anthony Bush | 2.17 | 2.23 | Anthony Bush |
| Strikeouts/9 IP | Jake Lewis | 10.47 | 10.35 | Jake Lewis |
| Strikeouts/Walks | Jake Lewis | 3.38 | 3.64 | Jake Lewis |